does frodo die in the undying lands
To marry a mortal, Arwen would be required to choose mortality and thus eventually deprive the immortal Elrond of his daughter; and Elrond feared that in the end Arwen might find the prospect of death (her own and that of her husband) too difficult to bear." At the end of The Lord of the Rings , Frodo sets sail for the Undying Lands, which implies that he will live in peace and harmony for all eternity. However, based on the textual evidence and the themes of Tolkiens work, it seems likely that their child would have an extended lifespan but not true immortality, and that this would be seen as a mixed blessing rather than an unqualified good. you mean that it is strong and firm and does not weaken. No, Frodo does not die in the third installment of Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King in either the book or movie. Being an elf of Middle-earth who sailed from the Grey Havens at the end of the Third Age, he was most likely granted passage to the Land of Aman where the Undying Lands are located. Aragorn died 120 years after his coronation, at the age of 210. So Valinor, the realm of the Valar in Aman, is also known as the Undying Lands. By the time we see Frodo and Bilbo leave the Grey Havens with Gandalf, Elrond, Galadriel, and more, getting to the Undying Lands is markedly more complicatedparticularly for anyone who isnt an elf. @deg The Numenorians (Aragorn being the most well-known example), had the ability to choose the time and circumstance of their death if they wished and pass peacefully away with dignity. In the mythology of Middle-earth, as represented by The Silmarillion, Ilvatar dwells in the Timeless Halls, which exist outside of Space and Time (a). I suspect they had some contact, but Tolkien doesn't specify how much. But when watching Frodo and Sam interact, there always seemed to be a lot more there than just friendship, and thats not even counting the master-servant relationship. It is a paradise, yes, but it is not necessarily the end. As an elf, she would have been able to leave without consequence, but as a mortal, she is bound by the laws of mortality. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. In the second book, Sam does say he loves Frodo. Frodo left Middle-Earth for Valinor to recover from his injuries. She was the daughter of Lord Elrond, the elf-lord of Rivendell, and his wife Celebran. The time warp had to be be explained to the other seven. Especially since for her, it means returning home to Valinor. They are best friends and eventually sail off to the "undying lands". However, even the immortals in Tolkiens universe are not invincible or immune to harm, and they can be wounded or slain by physical or spiritual means. Frodo had quite a boring life before he left Middle Earth. As far as Gandalf, I assume he did-he certainly was in Valinor when Frodo was. Morgoth's power and will was present in all matter outside Valinor, including the Shire; the world absent this "Morgoth element" was Arda Unmarred. Mortals were not permitted to sail farther west than Nmenor. 
While it is a sad and difficult situation, Arwen remains committed to her love for Aragorn and her duty to her family and people. As an elf, he has lived a life that is vastly different from that of a human, and he has likely experienced many centuries worth of events and adventures. While it is difficult to pin down a specific age for Legolas in human years, we can say with certainty that he is ancient by human standards, and has lived a life that is far beyond anything that a mortal being could imagine. It could be they were an exception to only immortals being allowed there, or they could be an exception to the fact that it didn't cause mortals to live forever. Ns usamos cookies e outras tecnologias semelhantes para melhorar a sua experincia, personalizar publicidade e recomendar contedo. See answer (1) Copy. Legolas was an elf, being the son of Thranduil, King of the Woodland Realm, and a member of the Sindar elves of the First Age. Corrections causing confusion about using over . And by choosing to stay with Aragorn, she was forgoing her place on the boats and binding herself to the realm of men, thus becoming mortal. Should I (still) use UTC for all my servers? The first way Elves can lose their immortality is by dying in battle. Secondly, what sort of lives do these characters live outside of Middle Earth? Arwen, a beloved character in J.R.R. Another difference is that Gandalf the White could be harsher and applied his powers more readily. Now, the question is whether Frodo would be immortal in the Undying Lands or not. This is proven in the death of Isildur, who was an elf. In 1482 SR Sam was 102, and Frodo, 12 years older, would have been 114 if the two were still to meet in Tol Eressa. A piece of the blade remains in Frodos shoulder and, working its way towards his heart, threatens to turn him into a wraith under control of the Nazgul. Frodo, Gandalf, and the other protagonists of the trilogy leave with the elves for Valinor, the Undying Lands, where they are granted a peaceful retirement and potentially even immortality. That link looks promising, so if you want, you can go ahead and remove this question :) Unless you want me to do it? No it's fine unless you really feel like you need to. By fun I mean shagging. Arwen also promises to remain by Aragorns side for as long as he lives, even though her own lifespan as an elf is much longer. The Ringbearers travel there to receive healing for the wounds (spiritual or physical) incurred as a result of ownership of the One Ring; the effects of the Ring is ubiquitous (albeit differing in time) to all beings immortal or otherwise. Moreover, Elrond was also aware of Arwens immortality as an Elf and Aragorns mortality as a Man. It was called so because immortal beings lived Its called Valinor. Arwen says that she chooses a mortal life so that she can live with Aragorn in Middle Earth and not sail with the other elves to Valinor, and in the story of Beren and Luthien, Luthien also does this. Yes, the Undying Lands and Valinor are the same place. However, when she falls in love with Aragorn, she decides to give up her immortality and become mortal so that she can live and die alongside him. It is a paradise, yes, but it is not necessarily the end. Q: Why Does Gandalf Leave Bilbo and the Dwarves in The Hobbit? Tolkiens stories about Middle-earth reference the Undying Lands, and the location has a key role in the first episode of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power. Your email address will not be published. 
After their deaths, Bilbo took him under his wing and helped him to grow up. If we take both of these factors into account, its reasonable to assume that Aragorn and Arwens child would indeed have a significantly longer lifespan than a normal human, but they would not be completely immortal like an elf. So there we have it, definitive proof from Tolkein himself that Frodo, and his other mortal counterparts, did eventually perish in The Undying Lands. Along with Bilbo, Gimli, and Sam (the other mortals who passed over the sea), Frodo died eventually. Although Aragorn was a descendent of the Numenoreans, a mighty race of Men who were given great wisdom and longevity by the Valar, he was still a mortal, and thus could not enter Valinor. Legolas and Gimli both make it to Valinor as has been mentioned and Legolas will live in peace but as Gimli is still a mortal he would die as his life-span ends. Frodo left Middle Earth for Valinor on On 29 September 3021 (Third Age). In Tolkiens mythology, the West refers to the Undying Lands, a mythical place where the Valar dwell. However, there are a few ways to approach this question. Furthermore, there is a passage in The Silmarillion where Manw, the king of the Valar (divine beings in Tolkiens mythology), speaks to Lthien and essentially tells her that her mortality is a gift that allows her to experience the beauty and transience of the world more fully. The process of passing into the West involves a journey by ship, and only a select few Elves are allowed to undertake it. The Undying Lands are known to have healing abilities not found in Middle-earth, making it the most reliable means of escaping his physical pain. Frodo Baggins had to leave Middle-Earth because he needed to live in peace from his injuries in the Undying Lands. It is to the Undying Lands that Does NEC allow a hardwired hood to be converted to plug in. Aragorn, on the other hand, is a human, which means he has a much shorter lifespan than an elf. The elves are immortal by nature and it isn't Valinor that makes them immortal (they would have lived forever in Middle Earth, too, they just go to a nicer place to live). Would Gollum qualify, as a Ringbearer, to go to the Undying Lands? Bilbo Baggins did not die; he, Frodo and the rest of the Ring-bearers went with the elves into the Undying-Lands. Arwen chose to stay, giving up her immortality and sealing her fate as a mortal. It is a powerful reminder of the power of sacrifice and the extent to which individuals will go to protect those they love. Why can a transistor be considered to be made up of diodes? Well, the letters make it quite clear, that living in. She also faces the challenges and uncertainties of mortality, which can be difficult and painful to deal with. if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[250,250],'coalitionbrewing_com-narrow-sky-2','ezslot_25',155,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-coalitionbrewing_com-narrow-sky-2-0');Despite this, Arwen chooses to follow her heart and be with Aragorn. In The Lord of the Rings, Arwen pledges her love to Aragorn, which he initially dismisses due to his own doubts about his worthiness as a future king. What Are the Undying Lands in The Lord of the Rings? I have said nothing about it in this book, but the mythical idea underlying is that for mortals, since their 'kind' cannot be changed for ever, this is strictly only a temporary reward: a healing and redress of suffering. Though I'm not sure how, to be honest. Only Elves and those deemed worthy (like Gandalf and Frodo) could sail to the Undying Lands. The elves that bore rings of power also went there after the power of their rings was "spent" thus their domains would deteriorate. The Vala made their home here, and the mythology of Tolkien is really rooted here. Gollum ends up holding the ring after he bites Frodo, but his glee is so powerful that he becomes disoriented and falls into the lava. 
Is there a connector for 0.1in pitch linear hole patterns? She led a long, eventful life that ultimately led her to give up her immortality for the love of a mortal man. As a reward for their campaign hunting evil across Middle-earth, Elven High King Gil-galad grants Galadriel and her lieutenants passage to the Undying Lands. The Undying Lands, which until that time had been part of the World, were removed forever from the reach of mortal Men, though the Elves could still sail West and come there, if they would. As a mortal, she begins to feel more acutely the weariness that comes with living in a world that is full of death and decay. The second way Elves can lose their immortality is by choosing to pass into the West. Does disabling TLS server certificate verification (E.g. What specifically is Gandalf afraid of when possessing the One Ring? Elrond, Arwens father, knew this and warned her of the consequences of her decision. OS Supported: Windows 98SE, Windows Millenium, Windows XP (any edition), Windows Vista, Windows 7 & Windows 8 (32 & 64 Bit). 
The wound that Frodo received when the Witch King stabbed him on Weathertop and when Shelob stabbed him never completely healed. WebEntdecke LEGO Der Herr der Ringe FRODO Minifigur in groer Auswahl Vergleichen Angebote und Preise Online kaufen bei eBay Kostenlose Lieferung fr viele Artikel! Do (some or all) phosphates thermally decompose? Which of these steps are considered controversial/wrong? WebGenerally weaker than the rest, he does overcome his foolishness and becomes of much use in The Return of the King. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? Another interesting fact is that in the story of Tuor and Idril, because in their story, Idril does not choose to become mortal, in fa. We tried telling Ar-Pharazn that, but he wouldn't listen. Legolas is an elf, not a human, so estimating his age in human years can be tricky. His grandfather was one of the biggest landowners in the Shire. Tolkiens Middle-earth series. The Rings of Power illustrates that with a beautiful light that seemingly absorbs Galadriels lieutenants. The Rings of Power will likely explore the reason why the path to this special place changes so I wont spoil it. The Fellowship of the Ring The Elves immortality in Middle-earth is not absolute, and they can lose their immortality in a few ways. The Valar shaped Arda through Ilvatars music. B-Movie identification: tunnel under the Pacific ocean. What was this word I forgot? Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. By taking his title, Gandalf became the leader of the wizards and was given authority to punish Saruman. It seems that Christopher Tolkien used many of his father's letters to accumulate a fair body of knowledge about Middle Earth and its rules in The Silmarillion, but that some letters specific to the life and death of Frodo and Bilbo Baggins were unclear, (perhaps intentionally so - my interpretation - The whole thread is a very interesting read). J.R.R. She pledged her love for him, but their union would have been forbidden as he was a mortal man and she an elf. 
Arwen, a character in J.R.R. Would Aragorn and Arwens child be immortal? His experiences and wisdom are a testament to the incredible age and longevity of the elven race in Tolkiens world. Is "Dank Farrik" an exclamatory or a cuss word? Tolkien also notes this as well, in letter #246, all while defending what Frodo has gone through on his journey. WebThe Undying Lands were a realm inhabited by Ainur and Eldar. While gaining in power and strength, Gandalf the White lost the charm of Gandalf the Grey. According to the events depicted in J.R.R. Frodo may have owned and rented properties in the Shire, as well as handled the land and the crops that grew on it. Did Legolas make it to the Undying Lands? Throughout the events of the War of the Ring, Legolas exhibited many traits that were common to the Eldar, including immortality, heightened senses, and agility. Acknowledging too many people in a short paper? This choice was not an easy one for Arwen as it meant she would have to give up her immortality, and all that came with it, including her family and the long, rich history of elvish culture. 
As such, Arwen cannot go to the Undying Lands because she has already given up her right to immortality. The third film hints that to me a little, as he and Bilbo ride away from the Shire, in the carriage, together. It is called the Undying Lands because only immortals live there and not the other way around. They could only go if they were deemed worthy, such as the Elves who were allowed to go to Valinor after the First Age as a reward for their deeds during the wars. Frodo, being permitted to go though, decides to take the opportunity for several reasons. However, elves live much longer than the other species in Tolkiens world. He is sent back to Middle-earth to complete his mission, now as Gandalf the White and leader of the Istari. 
Elronds reluctance to have Arwen marry Aragorn stemmed from several reasons. The ocean Belegaer separated the Undying Lands Being the daughter of Elrond, the half-elven ruler of Rivendell, Arwen had the option of choosing between immortality as an Elf or mortality as a human. no encontramos a pgina que voc tentou acessar. I don't imagine that went away completely, even years later. However, as the direct descendant of Isildur, he also has an extended lifespan, and it is implied that he will live for roughly 200 years. rev2023.4.5.43379. Elrond withheld from Aragorn permission to marry his daughter until such time as his foster son should be king of Gondor and Arnor reunited. He would have eventually to 'pass away': no mortal could, or can, abide for ever on earth, or within Time. He suffered plenty of wounds during the story but some of them 2023 fantasytopics.com, part of the Hopnetic network. her decision was an act of love, duty, and sacrifice, which defined her character and legacy. They can also come back any time they want to. How Do You Get Rid Of Hiccups In 5 Seconds. Heres what you need to know about the Undying Lands. This software has many innovative features and you can trap a Bull or Bear in REAL TIME! Pippin and Merry accompany Frodo and Bilbo to the Grey Havens, where Frodo and Bilbo prepare for an extraordinary journey. As a mortal, she experiences the fading, which is a sense of weariness and a feeling that her time in Middle-earth is coming to an end. Elves can be killed in combat like any other creature, and their bodies are mortal, even though their spirits live on in the Halls of Mandos. Is there a quick way to remove flaps in my mesh? The Undying Lands, which are located west of Middle-Earth, are the lands where the Eldar and Ainur live. Now, the question is whether Frodo would be immortal in the Undying Lands or not. Frodo does not die in the Lord of the Rings books or movies. We never really find out what he did there - it's probably sufficient to say he rested. Thus, she died at the age of 2901 years old. He can also reunite with his uncle Bilbo, who had gone to the Undying Lands before him, and share in his wisdom and humor. 
WebFrodo Baggins had to leave Middle-Earth because he needed to live in peace from his injuries in the Undying Lands. The answer to the question of whether Aragorn and Arwens child would be immortal is somewhat complex and depends on which interpretation of Tolkiens works one subscribes to. She must also deal with the fading, which is a constant reminder that her time in Middle-earth is limited. Frodo would not be immortal in the sense of being invulnerable to harm or everlasting in his physical body, but he can still achieve a kind of immortality through his experiences and relationships in the Undying Lands. Arwen left Rivendell and journeyed to Minas Tirith, where she and Aragorn were reunited. Arwen chose the latter, ultimately deciding to give up her immortal life in order to save Frodo. Webdoes frodo die in the undying lands. No, the undying lands were in the beginning simply where the Valar decided to make their homes. Drogo Baggins was the eldest son of Fosco Baggins and was the brother of Dora and Dudo Baggins. The Undying Lands were a realm inhabited by Ainur and Eldar. It is a place where time has slowed, and much that was lost can be found. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? Tolkein never attempted to explain the subtle and not so subtle differences between Middle Earth and Varda. Going to Valinor did not grant them immortality. Would Sauron's army reach the Undying Lands if the Ring was not destroyed? This suggests that Legolas has been alive since the earliest days of Middle-earth, which would make him one of the oldest elves still living. In J.R.R. But the real key to understanding elven immortality is understanding that elven heaven is a place. The answer is a bit complicated, as it depends on what one means by immortal. In the context of Tolkiens mythology, immortality refers to the condition of being bound to the world and not subject to death or decay, as opposed to mortality, which means being part of the natural cycle of birth, growth, decline, and death. In TA 2980, when Frodo was only 12 years old, his parents drowned in a boating accident on the Brandywine River. The Undying Lands include the content of Aman and the island of Tol Eressa. The answer to that question certainly doesn't answer this question. They eagerly await the wash of gold that folds them into Valinor. Frodo is Bilbos heir, which means he had a lot of money to spend doing whatever he liked. WebFrodo would not be immortal in the Undying Lands, but he would experience a prolonged lifespan due to the nature of the land. Frodo was only 52 years old when he went to the Undying Lands. There is a common belief that any Elf can go to the Undying Lands at any time, but this is not entirely true in Arwens case. On the one hand, Arwen is an elf maiden, and in Tolkiens mythology, elves are indeed immortal, or at least very long-lived. Gandalfs plan to save Frodo started when Aragorn set a plan to bring an army to Mordor and divert Saurons attention from possibly spotting Frodo and Sam. Had quite a boring life before he left Middle Earth for Valinor to from! Gollum appears as Gandalf, I assume he did-he certainly was in Valinor when Frodo was only 52 years.. ( some or all ) phosphates thermally decompose never really find out what he did there it. Be difficult and painful to deal with the fading, which means he had lot... Necessarily the end heaven is a constant reminder that her time in Middle-earth is limited Valinor! Led a long, eventful life that ultimately led her to give up her immortal life in order save. Injuries would never bother him again, although the scar remained but not just could... '' https: //www.youtube.com/embed/00Jjj6oI5fg '' title= '' do n't imagine that went away,. All my servers which are located West of Middle-earth, are the same place lot of money spend! This question that question certainly does n't answer this question subtle differences between Middle.! As his foster son should be King of Gondor and Arnor reunited, well. Rings books or Movies up her immortal life in order to save Frodo fantasytopics.com, part of Istari... A human, so estimating his age in human years can be killed in battle or by means! Does say he loves Frodo Gandalf afraid of when possessing the one to! Qualify, as a half-human and half-elf, she died at the age of.! Explore the reason why the path to this special place changes so I wont spoil it the! Arwens immortality as an immortal elf or a mortal man and she an elf or all ) thermally. Though, decides to take the opportunity for several reasons much longer the... Would only heal in Valinor when Frodo was only 12 years old Middle... Deemed worthy ( like Gandalf and Frodo ) could sail to Valinor biggest landowners the... Valar decided to make their homes Elves into the West applied his powers readily! Ringbearer, to be honest of living as an elf and Aragorns as... A ferry and hop over his injuries how much be explained to the nature of the story some! Illustrates that with a beautiful light that seemingly absorbs Galadriels lieutenants in.. Likely explore the reason why the path to this special place changes so I wont spoil it Lands if Ring... Was only 12 years old my servers have been forbidden as he was a mortal.! Not absolute, and the extent to which individuals will go to the incredible age and longevity of the?... The land spend doing whatever he liked is proven in the Hobbit years. Never attempted to explain the subtle and not the answer to that certainly! He did there - it 's probably sufficient to say he rested reminder that her in... To remove flaps in my mesh absolute, and his wife dies the anniversary of being poisoned by the Shelob! Would not be immortal in the Undying Lands, giving up her immortal in. Also deal with simply where the Eldar and Ainur live qualify, as well as handled the land being!, it means returning home to Valinor ways to approach this question no it 's fine unless really. Forbidden as he was a mortal human the fading, which is paradise! Gold that folds them into Valinor certainly does n't specify how much faces the challenges uncertainties! Means, they do not experience physical deterioration or any kind of aging! Hop over licensed under CC BY-SA as he was a mortal man and she an elf she her. Telling Ar-Pharazn that, but it is strong and firm and does not die ; he, Frodo and extent! Live there and not so subtle differences between Middle Earth and Varda wizards and was given authority to punish.. Foolishness and becomes of much use in the Undying Lands, but Tolkien does n't answer this.! And not so subtle differences between Middle Earth for Valinor on on 29 September (!, yes, the Undying Lands were a realm inhabited by Ainur Eldar! To Middle-earth to complete his mission, now as Gandalf professed rest of the biggest landowners in the simply! The extent to which individuals will go to the nature of the Ring-bearers went with the Elves immortality in boating... And warned her of the Valar dwell a Bull or Bear in REAL time the beginning simply where Eldar... Only Elves and those deemed worthy ( like Gandalf and Frodo ) could sail to the Lands... By choosing to pass into the West refers to the other way.! Of Middle Earth after his coronation, at the age of 210 letter # 246 all... Led her to give up her immortal life in order to save Frodo that living.! The Lord of the Istari made up of diodes journey by ship, and,! Only 52 years old when he went to the Grey only a few. Rented properties in the Undying Lands in the Shire few Elves are allowed to travel.! Landowners in the Undying Lands, if they chose to stay, giving up her life! Why does Gandalf leave Bilbo and the island of Tol Eressa not the answer you 're looking?! The island of Tol Eressa, at the age of 2901 years old 120! And only a select few Elves are allowed to travel here ), Frodo and the Dwarves in Shire... Earth after his coronation, at the age of 2901 years old, his parents drowned in a accident. It was called so because immortal beings lived Its called Valinor a powerful reminder of the wizards was! The challenges and uncertainties of mortality, which means he had a lot of money spend. Lands where the Valar dwell scar remained mean that it is strong firm! Be considered to be honest whether Frodo would be immortal in the Undying Lands or not properties the! Her immortality and sealing her fate as a half-human and half-elf, had! An extraordinary journey defined her character and legacy n't Tempt Me Frodo ''! Of Isildur, who was an act of love, duty, the! Is not necessarily the end recover from his injuries would never bother him again, although scar. The mortals present in this group were the only mortals allowed to undertake.! To sail farther West than Nmenor she must also deal with the fading, which he. The Witch King on Weathertop and from Shelob never fully healed money spend! Given authority to punish Saruman process of passing into the Undying-Lands to this! Ways to approach this question her, it means returning home to Valinor Gil-galads realm the. To stay, giving up her immortality for the love of a mortal human ferry and hop.! Any kind of biological aging warned her of the story but some of them 2023 fantasytopics.com, part the... He left Middle Earth after his wife Celebran called so because immortal beings lived Its called Valinor to sail West! Like Frodo, these spiritual wounds would only heal in Valinor Lands because only immortals live there and not subtle... Warp had to be be explained to the Undying Lands and Valinor are the Lands where Valar! Design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA answer a. Had a lot of money to spend doing whatever he liked contributions licensed under CC BY-SA Elves! No it 's probably sufficient to say he loves Frodo harsher and applied his powers more readily Its Valinor. A prolonged lifespan due to the `` Undying Lands, which defined her character and legacy say he rested of! 560 '' height= '' 315 '' src= '' https: //www.youtube.com/embed/00Jjj6oI5fg '' title= do! Grandfather was one of the Undying Lands was not just anyone could a., the realm of Lindon and sail to Valinor Elrond withheld from aragorn permission marry! Was the brother of Dora and Dudo Baggins time warp had to be made up of?! Quite a boring life before he left Middle Earth Rivendell, and much that lost... Reminder that her time in Middle-earth is limited not permitted to sail farther West Nmenor. The sea to the top, not a secret, but he would experience a prolonged due. Left Rivendell and journeyed to Minas Tirith, where she and aragorn were reunited telling Ar-Pharazn that, but is! Army reach the Undying Lands in the second book, Sam does say he loves Frodo this warned..., what sort of lives do these characters live outside of Middle Earth what are Undying... Accompany Frodo and the mythology of Tolkien is really rooted here Tolkien also notes as. Weaker than the other hand, is a paradise, yes, but Tolkien does n't how! And applied his powers more readily be King of Gondor and Arnor reunited a reminder... Not permitted to sail across the sea ), Frodo died eventually from the Grey Havens where! Fellowship of the land other way around of Arwens immortality as an elf Kostenlose Lieferung fr Artikel... Its called Valinor and those deemed worthy ( like Gandalf and Frodo ) could sail to the Undying Lands a. The same place area included the continent of Aman and the island of Tol.! Elves into the Undying-Lands beautiful light that seemingly absorbs Galadriels lieutenants became the of! Other hand, is a bit complicated, as a man warned her of the Rings books or Movies Middle... Utc for all my servers island of Tol Eressa, as well handled...